After a judge ruled in August 1906 that the City of Little Rock could not build a new City Hall and Auditorium complex, it looked like Little Rock would be stuck with its existing inadequate building.
However on September 10 it became obvious that much work had been taking place behind the scenes after that ruling. On that day, the Board of Public Affairs (a City body charged with overseeing municipal government construction projects and comprised of the mayor and two citizens approved by the City Council) voted to ask the aldermen to cancel plans and rescind legislation for the city hall, jail and auditorium complex. The Board of Public Affairs then offered up a new plan for a city hall and jail building. Because no auditorium was involved, these plans would not be in violation of the Chancery Court.
That same evening the City Council followed suit and revoked the plans for the original project. The aldermen then voted to proceed with building a new city hall and jail without the auditorium. There was only one dissenting vote; Alderman Jonathan Tuohey voted no. He explained his negative vote was not a lack of support for the project, but he was not comfortable with the way it was rushed through.
Mayor Warren E. Lenon told the Gazette, “The Chancery Court has enjoined us from erecting an auditorium and the Board of Public Affairs has consequently rescinded all resolutions and orders pertaining to that structure.” He noted that there would “be no appeal from the injunction granted by Chancellor Hart, because there is nothing to appeal.”
The coverage of the actions of the City Council that night was in keeping with the manner in which the two daily newspapers had covered the lawsuit and the trial. The Gazette headline cried “City Hall Ordinance Railroaded Through” while the staid Democrat merely stated “New $175,000 City Hall Provided by City Council.” The tone of theGazette’s article matched the headline while the Democrat’s story was more straightforward.
Architect Charles Thompson adjusted his plan for the new City Hall by removing the auditorium wing. With the revised Th0mpson plan and the approval of the City Council, Little Rock was at last on its way to a new City Hall. This was over two years after Mayor Lenon had first broached the subject.
Originally slated to open in 1907, the building officially opened in April 1908.